FragIndex

Best Creed Carmina Clones & Dupes

Compare the closest alternatives to Creed Carmina by similarity, ratings, longevity, projection, and community votes.

The Verdict

ALT. Fragrances Melodia is the top-ranked clone.

Based on our ratings, this is currently the closest match for Creed Carmina.

Other Ranked Clones

Montagne Parfums Cashmere Rose

#2 of 12 clones

Montagne Parfums Cashmere Rose

FragIndex finds Cashmere Rose a close and polished interpretation of Creed Carmina, with the resemblance strongest in its vivid cherry-rose character and smooth, softly resinous drydown. It can present a slightly darker, richer cherry opening and a more prominent rose than the original, which adds impact but may feel too floral for rose-sensitive wearers. Projection is assertive and longevity is consistently strong, making it especially effective in cooler weather, while its refined sweetness and feminine character suit both dressed-up occasions and confident everyday wear.

Unranked Clones

Compare All Clones

Creed Carmina

Rating

—

Concentration

Eau de Parfum

Longevity

—

Projection

—
ALT. Fragrances Melodia

Similarity

90%(1 vote)

Rating

4.0(1 vote)

Concentration

Parfum

Longevity

Long(1 vote)

Projection

Strong(1 vote)
Montagne Parfums Cashmere Rose

Similarity

88%(1 vote)

Rating

4.0(1 vote)

Concentration

Eau de Parfum

Longevity

Long(1 vote)

Projection

Strong(1 vote)
Alexandria Fragrances Cherry De Carmen

Similarity

—

Rating

—

Concentration

Parfum

Longevity

—

Projection

—
Bujairami Empress

Unranked clone

Bujairami Empress

Similarity

—

Rating

—

Concentration

Unknown

Longevity

—

Projection

—
Barrett Fragrances Secret Gardena Inspired by Carmina

Similarity

—

Rating

—

Concentration

Parfum

Longevity

—

Projection

—
Be Layered Karmina Swirl

Similarity

—

Rating

—

Concentration

Eau de Parfum

Longevity

—

Projection

—
Oil Perfumery Impression of Creed - Carmina

Similarity

—

Rating

—

Concentration

Unknown

Longevity

—

Projection

—
Maison Alhambra Maison Alhambra Avant Ruby Eau de Parfum for Women

Similarity

—

Rating

—

Concentration

Eau de Parfum

Longevity

—

Projection

—
Hamidi Legacy Cleopatra

Similarity

—

Rating

—

Concentration

Eau de Parfum

Longevity

—

Projection

—
The DUA Brand The Poem

Similarity

—

Rating

—

Concentration

Parfum

Longevity

—

Projection

—
Zimaya Charisma Pour Femme

Similarity

—

Rating

—

Concentration

Eau de Parfum

Longevity

—

Projection

—
Oakcha Rosalina

Unranked clone

Oakcha Rosalina

Similarity

—

Rating

—

Concentration

Parfum

Longevity

—

Projection

—

Related Clone Lists